Binyon's Dante

Laurence Binyon's translation of Dante's Divine Comedy.

Hover over the green Roman numerals for Charles Hall Grandgent's annotations.

The PDF version, with more assured formatting, can be found here.

Paradiso

Canto III

Dante becomes aware of faces appearing eager to speak to him. At first he supposes them to be reflections (unlike Narcissus, who supposed his reflection to be real). One of these spirits is Piccarda, about whom Dante had asked her brother Forese in Purgatory (Canto XXIV). She is with those placed in the sphere of the Moon because of vows Fakes or imperfectly performed. Dante asks if those who are in this lowest sphere ever crave for a more exalted place in Paradise. She tells him that this is impossible; it is of the essence of their bliss merely to fulfil the divine will: “In His will is our peace.” And she goes on to tell how she took the veil in the Order of Saint Clare, but was forcibly taken from her convent (to be married to a noble). Among these spirits is the Empress Constance, who also was torn from her convent and married to Henry VI, the second of the three “whirlwinds” from Suabia (line 119); the first being Frederick Barbarossa, and the third Frederick II; all these emperors were men of tempestuous energy.


THAT Sun which fired my bosom of old with love[i]1. “That Sun”: Beatrice.

Had thus bared for me in beauty the aspect sweet

Of truth, expert to prove as to disprove;

And I, to avow me of all error quit,

Confident and assured, lifted my head

More upright, in such measure as was fit.

But now appeared a sight that riveted

Me to itself with such compulsion keen

That my confession from my memory fled.

As from transparent glasses polished clean, [10]

Or water shining smooth up to its rim,

Yet not so that the bottom is unseen,

Our faces’ lineaments return so dim

That pearl upon white forehead not more slow

Would on our pupils its pale image limn;

So I beheld faces that seemed aglow

To speak, and fell into the counter-snare

From what made love ’twixt man and pool to grow.[ii]18. “Man”: Narcissus (see the Argument).

No sooner had I marked those faces there,

Than, thinking them reflections, with swift eyes [20]

I turned about to see of whom they were,

And saw nothing: again, in my surprise,

I turned straight to the light of my sweet Guide,

Who smiling, burned within her sainted eyes.

“Marvel not at my smiling,” she replied,

“To contemplate thy childlike thought revealed

Which cannot yet its foot to truth confide,

But moves thee, as ever, on emptiness to build.

True substances are these thine eyes perceive,

Remitted here for vows not all fulfilled. [30]

Speak with them therefore, hearken and believe,

For the true light which is their happiness

Lets them not swerve, but to it they must cleave.”

And I to the shade that seemed most near to press

For converse, turned me and began, as one

Who is overwrought through longing in excess:

“O spirit made for bliss, who from the sun

Of life eternal feelest the sweet ray

Which, save ’tis tasted, is conceived by none,

It will be gracious to me, if I may [40]

Be gladdened with thy name and all your fate.”

And she, with laughing eyes and no delay:

“Our charity no more locks up the gate

Against a just wish than that Charity[iii]44. “That Charity”: of God.

Which would have all its court in like estate.

On earth I was a Virgin Sister: see

What memory yields thee, and my being now

More beautiful will hide me not from thee,

But that I am Piccarda thou wilt know,

Who with these other blessed ones placed here [50]

Am blessed in the sphere that moves most slow;

For our desires, which kindle and flame clear

Only in the pleasure of the Holy Ghost,

To what he appointeth joyfully adhere;

And this which seems to thee so lowly a post

Is given to us because the vows we made

Were broken, or complete observance lost.”

Then I to her: “Something divinely glad

Shines in your marvellous aspect, to replace

In you the old conceptions that I had; [60]

I was slow therefore to recall thy face:

But what thou tell’st me helpeth now to clear

My sight, and thee more easily to retrace.

But tell me: you that are made happy here,

Do ye to a more exalted place aspire,

To see more, or to make yourselves more dear?”

She smiled a little, and with her smiled that choir

Of spirits; then so joyous she replied

That she appeared to burn in love’s first fire:

“Brother, the virtue of love hath pacified [70]

Our will; we long for what we have alone,

Nor any craving stirs in us beside.

If we desired to reach a loftier zone,

Our longings would be all out of accord

With His will who disposeth here His own.

For that, these circles, thou wilt see, afford

No room, if love be our whole being’s root

And thou ponder the meaning of that word.

Nay, ’tis of the essence of our blessed lot

In the divine will to be cloistered still [80]

Through which our own wills into one are wrought,

As we from step to step our stations fill

Throughout this realm, to all the realm ’tis bliss

As to its King, who wills us into His will;

And in His will is perfected our peace.

It is the sea whereunto moveth all

That it creates and nature makes increase.”

Then saw I how each heaven for every soul

Is paradise, though from the Supreme Good

The dews of grace not in one measure fall. [90]

But as may hap, when sated with one food

Still for another we have appetite,

We ask for this, and that with thanks elude,

Such words and gesture used I that I might

Learn from her what that web was where she plied

The shuttle and yet drew not the head outright.

“Perfect life and high merit have enskied

A Lady above,” she said, “whose rule they take[iv]98. “A Lady above”: St. Clare, the friend of St. Francis; she founded the order that bears her name.

In your world who in robe and veil abide,

That they till death may, sleeping and awake, [100]

Be with that Spouse who giveth welcome free

To all vows love may for His pleasure make.

To follow her, a young girl, did I flee

The world and, closed within her habit, vowed

Myself to the pathway of her company.

Afterwards men, used to evil more than good,[v]106. “Men”: her brother Corso Donati and his followers.

Tore me away, out of the sweet cloister;

And God knows then what way of life I trod.

This other splendour whom thou see’st appear

To thee on my right side, who, glowing pale, [110]

Kindles with all the radiance of our sphere,

Can of herself tell also the same tale.

She was a Sister; from her head they tore

Likewise the shadow of the sacred veil.

She was turned back into the world once more

Against her will, against good usage too;

Yet still upon her heart the veil she wore.

This is the light of the great Constance, who[vi]118. “The great Constance”: see the Argument.

From Suabia’s second whirlwind was to bring

To birth the third Power, and the last ye knew.” [120]

Thus spoke she to me, and then began to sing

Ave Maria, and singing disappeared,

As through deep water sinks a heavy thing.

My sight, which followed far as it was powered,

When it had lost her, turned and straightway shot

To the other mark, more ardently desired,

And Beatrice, only Beatrice, it sought.

But she upon my look was flaming so

That at the first my sight endured it. not;

And this made me for questioning more slow. [130]


Previous | Next